Chapter 1

“TO EXIST & TO CHOOSE”
Physis & Nomos
Evren Öztürk 12 October 2026DOI of the registered version (TR) 10.5281/zenodo.23310871
An English account of the chapter — the registered text is Turkish · details
The registered text of this chapter is Turkish, published on Zenodo with its own DOI (10.5281/zenodo.23310871). This page carries a detailed account of the chapter in English — its argument, its distinctive claims and its concepts — and links to the Turkish text. The authorised English translation will be published with the English edition of the book; the canonical text is the book itself.
The chapter's full text is in Turkish. These buttons open your own assistant with a ready-made instruction: read that page and explain the chapter in English.
Since the Sophists, physis (nature) and nomos (law, custom, convention) have been read as opposing poles: is human behaviour given by nature or made by society? Physis Theory accepts the distinction but rejects the opposition. Physis is the embodied form of the universal imperative to survive; it is the default, and everything operates within it. Nomos is not a set of rules but a capacity for conscious choice and meaning, born where memory meets death awareness, and it remains inside Physis. The capacity is morally neutral: it can serve cooperation or domination, and its direction is not guaranteed. The chapter's central thesis follows from this: the agonistic (competitive) side of Physis scales without resistance, while the affiliative side reaches scale only with high friction and constant erosion; Nomos cannot close the gap, because the rules meant to restore balance are made by those who hold power. The registered text of the chapter is Turkish, published on Zenodo with a DOI.
Abstract
The first chapter of the book establishes the theory's two founding concepts: Physis, the embodied form of the universal imperative to survive, and Nomos, the capacity for conscious choice that arises within it. The chapter distinguishes the agonistic and affiliative mechanisms of Physis, gives their neurobiological grounding, defines the threshold separating humans from other species through six capacities, and lays the ground for the rest of the book under the headings of existence, survival, the legitimacy test, interwovenness and the paradox of the corporate entity.
Concepts defined in this work 15
Concepts used in this work 2
The full text of this chapter is published in Turkish: read it here — your browser will translate the page, or the assistant buttons above will read that text and explain the chapter in English. What follows here is a detailed account of the chapter in English: its argument, its distinctive claims, and its concepts, each linked to its page in the concept library.
Core proposition
History is most often told as a march: humanity pursuing the ideal of a just, free and equal society, and drawing a little closer to it in every age. Even two great narratives hostile to one another make the same sentence — history walks in a direction, and that direction is an ideal. Yet each time, after a while, an invisible force enters the system: fraternity dissolves, equality is corrupted, justice is instrumentalized, freedoms narrow. Physis Theory proposes that these are not disconnected historical events but appearances of one and the same structural mechanism under different conditions.
Two concepts carry that mechanism: Physis, the embodied form of the universal necessity of survival — it is the default, and everything operates within it; and Nomos, the capacity for conscious choice and meaning, arising at the intersection of memory and death awareness. The two are not opposing poles; Nomos is born within Physis and remains within it.
And Physis is not one-dimensional: it carries two independent functions, the agonistic and the affiliative. The book's central thesis is the asymmetry of friction between them — the agonistic side advances at scale without resistance, while the affiliative side stays within its own near range; and Nomos cannot close that gap, because whoever would make the balancing rules is the holder of power.
What the text builds
- Basic Concepts. Physis and Nomos are defined and the Sophists' construction of them as opposites is rejected. The agonistic and affiliative functions of Physis are separated by their profiles; the critical difference is sensitivity to scale. Two axes — the ontological (Physis/Nomos) and the functional (agonistic/affiliative) — intersect to give the four cells that later chapters will fill. The elevating function assigned to Nomos by Plato and Aristotle is rejected: Nomos is a capacity, and its direction is not guaranteed.
- Neurobiological Foundations. Physis is situated in the limbic system and the capacity of Nomos in the prefrontal cortex — but this is shorthand: Nomos operates not as a region but as a network the PFC coordinates. What sets the human apart is that the PFC makes it possible to process death awareness continuously and in the abstract. The PFC's control over the limbic system is fragile, and the thought of death is among the threats that weaken it.
- The Human–Other Species Distinction. What is questioned is not the existence of the line but its nature: not a ladder of worth but a difference of degree — yet a difference of degree that crosses a qualitative threshold. Six capacities cross it. Why they came together only in the human is answered by the feedback loop: it begins in other species too, and does not close.
- Existence. Existence is not survival. Every living thing exists; the human knows that it exists. Existence is individual even at the most basic level of Physis — it cannot be shared, transferred or represented — and this leaves a solitude that never closes. To say "I am" is a claim against time, against nature, and before others. Memory and death awareness together give rise to linear time consciousness, and that in turn to three capacities: choice, scale, and temporal symbolic selfhood.
- Survival. Survival is the living form of the act of remaining. In other species it is a continuity won again at every moment; in the human it becomes a conscious aim. It operates simultaneously on five fronts, and none of them suffices alone. Individual victory over entropy is impossible; the group carries the act of remaining beyond the individual.
- The Legitimacy Test. Everything that exists can also end; that capacity to end opens every existence to an uninterrupted test. Legitimacy is determined not by approval but by outcome: a claim is legitimate to the degree that it can go on existing — and this has nothing to do with being right. The test works in two layers, and the layers accumulate: the upper does not annul the test of the lower.
- Interwovenness. The traditional layered model — first drive, then will — is rejected. Nomos operates at different intensities in different domains; hence there is no door through which one could say "now I am in Physis, now in Nomos". The conflict is not a transition to be managed but the structure itself.
- The Paradox of the Corporate Entity. The corporate entity is a product of Nomos yet takes its direction from the agonistic side of Physis. The one difference that explains the contradiction is the source of death: the human's inevitable source of death is entropy, the corporate entity's is the others. From here the three conditions of the capacity of Nomos are derived and used as a criterion throughout the rest of the book.
Distinctive claims
- The agonistic and affiliative functions of Physis are not opposite ends but two independent functions, differently sensitive to scale and operating at the same time. Comparable dualities in philosophy mostly assume a single-axis tension in which one rises as the other falls; this distinction does not sit on that axis.
- The asymmetry is at bottom an asymmetry of friction. Scaling the agonistic side runs without resistance because it aligns with the interest of the decision-maker and of a system composed of corporate entities; scaling the affiliative side strikes the resistance of that very power, because it would constrain it. The instrument that ought to provide the balance is in the hands of whoever benefits from the imbalance. This is why the asymmetry in Physis does not close in Nomos but is carried into Nomos amplified.
- Nomos is morally neutral. Plato and Aristotle assign it an elevating function; Nietzsche sees the dominance of Physis but codes Nomos as a weakness; both are assignments of function — one positive, the other negative. The theory accepts the dominance but defines Nomos as a neutral capacity: the capacity for conscious choice is also the capacity for conscious destruction.
- Legitimacy is determined by outcome, not approval — and this is the reverse of the best-known formula of outcome-based legitimacy. It does not say that whoever stands is right; whoever stands merely stands, their claim has passed the test, and it will go on being tested until it is lost. The concept is also extended beyond consciousness and beyond any recognizing environment, down to the bacterium and out to the galaxy.
- The corporate entity is a manifestation of Nomos but does not carry the capacity of Nomos; being a product is not carrying the producing capacity. Its lack of a brake is not a deficiency of hardware but a consequence of its formula: the formula does not call up the affiliative side of Physis — it suppresses it where it conflicts with its interest and instrumentalizes it where it serves. Nomos can be dictated to it only through the humans within it, with friction and temporarily.
Core concepts
- Physis: The embodied form of the universal necessity of survival. It is the default: fast, automatic, requiring no conscious effort, and it cannot be switched off. It is not one-dimensional; it carries two independent functions, the agonistic and the affiliative.
- Nomos: The capacity for conscious choice and meaning. It is not a content but a capacity; it is born within Physis and remains within it. It arises at the intersection of memory and death awareness, in linear time consciousness. It is morally neutral.
- Agonistic: The function that brings forward the individual's claim to power: aggression, competition, dominance, the production of leadership, hierarchy and the building of structures. Its distinguishing property is that it operates independently of scale.
- Affiliative: The relational function: it forms bonds, holds the group together, produces balance and repair. Empathy, reciprocity and the sense of justice belong here. Its distinguishing property is sensitivity to scale — strong in the near range, weak at scale.
- Structural asymmetry (asymmetry of friction): That the agonistic side scales without resistance while the affiliative side can be carried to scale only with high friction and continuous erosion. The book's central thesis.
- The capacities of Nomos (choice · scale · temporal symbolic selfhood): The three derivative faculties to which linear time consciousness gives rise. Choice: being able to act contrary to what Physis dictates. Scale: being able to build systems that outlast an individual life. Temporal symbolic selfhood: being able to locate the "I" in time.
- Death awareness: The thought "one day I will not be": abstract, temporal, inevitable. It is specific to the human and, joined with memory, gives rise to linear time consciousness.
- Linear time consciousness: The mode of time arising from the combination of memory and death awareness: past, present, future, and after death. In other species time remains largely cyclical, instinctive and centred on the "now".
- The individuality of existence: That existence is individual even at the most basic level of Physis — it cannot be shared, transferred or represented. It leaves in every living thing's existence a solitude that never closes; the solitude does not disappear, but empathy and bonds make it bearable.
- To be / to remain: The two basic acts of existence. To be: existing now. To remain: being, spread out in time. In other species remaining is largely cyclical; in the human it is linear — and one step further: "will I remain after my death?"
- The legitimacy test: The uninterrupted test arising from the capacity of everything that exists to end: can it go on existing? What is tested is the claim that what exists puts forward; neither the claim nor the test requires consciousness. Legitimacy is determined by outcome, not approval. It works in both directions: the one who governs tests, and so does the one governed.
- The two layers of the legitimacy test: The first layer is not a question but a claim — "I am, I am alive"; it is immediate, drive-level and universal. The second is specific to the human and arises from death awareness — "will I exist tomorrow, what will remain after me"; it requires time and a subject.
- Interwovenness: That Nomos is not a layer added on top of Physis but a capacity born within it and operating at different intensities in different domains. The conflict runs not between two parties but within every decision and every bond.
- Nomos intensity: That Nomos operates with different force across domains. High: beliefs, ideologies, the existential search for meaning. Low: monetary relations, calculations of immediate interest. In balance: shared danger, suffering lived through together. The two intensities are not complements of one another.
- Source of death: The structural cause of an entity's annihilation. The human's inevitable source of death is entropy — time and the body; others are at times allies and at times threats. The corporate entity's true source of death is the others — rivals, the market, competition.
- The conditions of Nomos: The three conditions the capacity of Nomos requires; if even one is missing, there is no Nomos. (1) Death awareness. (2) The formula of survival with others. (3) That the source of death is not structurally the others.
- The paradox of the corporate entity: That a structure which is a manifestation of Nomos takes its direction from the agonistic side of Physis. It operates the products of Nomos, but being a product is not carrying the producing capacity. As the manifestations of Nomos scale, so does the corporate entity; and because it is locked to the agonistic side, that side scales with less friction.
- The chain of permanence: The order followed by the permanence that power conflict produces — leadership, the governing classes, the corporate entity, hegemony; each layered upon the one before. And hegemony calls forth resistance.
Place in the book
Chapter 1 is the book's ground, and it carries a warning of its own: the presentation is linear by necessity, while the mechanism it describes is cyclical. It establishes the four-cell grid here but does not fill it — the grid is first applied in Chapter 5, given shape in On Equality through the placement of three concepts, and set up in full in Chapter 9. In the same way, the proposition that Physis and Nomos are not separate layers but interwoven components is offered here as the book's foundation yet cannot be shown; the place where it becomes testable is Chapter 9. It hands power conflict — the mechanism that produces the chain of permanence — to Chapter 2; and it leaves the three conditions of the capacity of Nomos to the whole book as a criterion — their consequences are tested above all in Chapter 5.
Works that build on this
Related book
How to cite
Öztürk, E. (2026). Bölüm 1: Physis & Nomos [Chapter 1: Physis & Nomos]. In Physis: Bir Güç Teorisi [Physis: A Theory of Power] (v1). Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23310871
BibTeX
@incollection{ozturk2026chapterphysisnomos,
author = {Öztürk, Evren},
title = {Bölüm 1: Physis \& Nomos},
booktitle = {Physis: Bir Güç Teorisi},
chapter = {1},
year = {2026},
publisher = {Zenodo},
version = {v1},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.23310871},
language = {turkish},
note = {Chapter 1: Physis \& Nomos. In: Physis: A Theory of Power},
url = {https://physisproject.com/tr/teori/physis-ve-nomos/}
}